Mental illness should not be a scapegoat for violence

By Matthew Thomson - Staff Reporter



Attempts to dismiss the mass shootings in the United States as a mental health problem and not a gun issue is unfairly stigmatizing the mentally ill, two mental health advocates told a Highline audience recently.

A frequent refrain following the increasingly frequent mass shootings has been to link the perpetrators to the mentally ill.

This argument has increasingly been advanced by gun advocates to counter calls for gun control and has been perpetuated in media coverage of mass shooting incidents.

Duke University psychiatry professor Jeffrey Swanson recently told the National Alliance on Mental Illness that re- searchers of mental illness have a "strong responsibility" to try and debunk the mental illness/ gun violence myth.

"Mental illness is not a very big part of the problem of gun violence in the United States," Swanson said.

According to NAMI, 96 percent of the violence in America has nothing to do with mental illness.

Highline's Access Services invited Darya Farivar and David Lord of Disability Rights Washington to address assertions that gun violence is caused by mental illness.

DRW advocates on behalf of people with mental illness and has three main goals: to humanize a stigmatized group, i.e. people with mental illness; to show that while some people with mental ill- ness are beyond help, the people committing these actions are the exception, not the rule; and to educate that just locking up the mentally ill is not a solution to the problem of gun violence. Treatment, however, may be.

"It is really unusual for someone with mental illness to commit acts of violence, and those that do are the exception, not the rule," Lord said.

"You see a person on the street, maybe they are talking to themselves or to an object and that is the common perception of insanity," he said.

Lord said he realizes that often the average person does not have a great deal of inter- action with the mentally ill and that the few interactions they do have are with the homeless, an already stigmatized and poverty-stricken group.

DRW advocates see this minimal interaction as problematic. While its goal is not to normalize mental illness, it is to humanize those who suffer from it.

DRW also seeks to advocate for the rights of all individuals with disabilities through class action suits and education, Farivar said.

In 2017, DRW sued on be- half of mentally ill people being held in prison. These people were not given competency hearings to establish their ability to stand trial.

The court determined that this violated the civil rights of the individuals and that the state had to provide hearings within 14 days of arrest.

Furthermore, most of the people cited in this suit were arrested for poverty-related crimes: trespassing, minor theft and the like, Lord said.

The way laws are set up, the government cannot restrict access to one group without also restricting access to all other groups, so all groups must be given equal access, he said.

"[It doesn't] make sense to restrict access when someone hasn't demonstrated they are a risk to themselves or oth- ers," Lord said.

DRW won the class action suit against the state of Wash- ington, resulting in more than $50 million in fines to the state.

Despite the growing num- ber of politicians blaming mental illness for the epidem- ic of gun violence, DRW plans to continue to advocate for treatment and recovery for the mentallyill.

What is needed is funding, public support, and education. When the mentally ill recover they can then become productive members of society, Farivar said.

DRW plans to accomplish this by supporting education for people with mental illness, bringing class action suits when appropriate, and educating the public through events like the one held at Highline, Farivar said.

The Brice is right: Highline professor wins award

A Highline professor has received an award at the 23rd Annual Washington State...


Transit station could mean more local development

A vision for an elevated light rail station located in the Kent/ Des Moines ar...


Day celebrates indigenous people

Highline will celebrate Indige- nous Peoples Day with two presen- tations on M...

Food bank feeds community needs

The Des Moines Area Food Bank will be hosting a Thanksgiving service where fam...


Social Media has pros and cons, students say

Highline students said that while social media is time consuming and addictive...


Vet. Services hopes for more space, resources

Most students wouldn't know it by the campus website or even signs around camp...

Construction still claiming parking spots

Traffic has gotten worse in Highline park- ing lots, specifically the North an...


Have coffee with a cop next week

Public Safety hopes having a cup of joe with a police officer will help you se...


Club's fundraising helps former student

After months of struggling with a rare eye condition, former student and Psych...


Club Fair next Tuesday

If you want to join a club at Highline but have questions, visit the Club Fair next Tuesday. The fair will take place in the Mt. Constance room in Building 8. The fair will occur from 11 a.m.-1:30 p.m. on Jan. 23, and will have representatives from many of the clubs on campus.

Help with Transfer Portfolio

Students who are planning on transferring to a four-year school but need help with their personal statement essay can attend a seminar on Thursday, Feb. 1. The event will take place in the MESA Center in Building 25 from 12:15-1:15 p.m. Students who want their portfolios reviewed by a representative from surrounding colleges will have that opportunity on Thursday, Feb. 8. The event will take place in the Mt. Constance room from 1:30-4 p.m. Students must register by Jan. 25. You can register in Building 6 in the Transfer Center, or online at bit.ly/tprd-wtr18.

Women's Programs giving tree brings gifts to children

The annual Women’s Program Giving Tree raised enough contributions to help 27 families, which helped give gifts to 70 children. The Women Program and WorkFirst Services Office sponsored the event in December.

Academic Success Centers open house

The Academic Success Centers is holding an open house today from 10:30 a.m. to 3 p.m. on floor 6 of the Library. Students will be able to inquire about AANAPISI, the Math Resource Center, MESA, Puente, the Tutoring Center, Umoja, and the Writing Center. The Academic Success Centers offers help on assignments, and has tutoring services.

Mental illness should not be a scapegoat for violence

Take a break from social media

'Pokemon', 'Battlefield' reach new levels

T-Birds come up short in semifinals

Veterans Service here to assist veterans

The Brice is right: Highline professor wins award

Veterans' Services deserves better

Dancers mix it up with PNB's 'All Premiere'

Men's soccer falls to Whatcom 2-0 in semifinals

Construction still claiming parking spots

Transit station could mean more local development

Faith and intellect can add up

Queer Love art competition accepting submissions

Men's wrestling takedown Big Bend

Have coffee with a cop next week

Day celebrates indigenous people

The man who changed the war

Three dances become one at PNB's latest show

Lady T-Birds ride strong finish into volleyball playoffs

Club's fundraising helps former student